• Multigenerational Family/Famille multigénérationnelle

Sharing a Roof: Multi-generational Homes in Canada

Nathan Battams

Home is at the heart of family life, where family relationships are formed and nurtured throughout the life cycle. It’s also where family resources – which include finances, food, living space and personal energy – are managed and where families provide care and support. Family resource management is an important factor in multi-generational households (those housing three or more generations), which now number 363,000 across Canada. The total population living in multi-generational households stands at 1.3 million (up from 930,000 in 2001) and is home to 4.5% of Canada’s population (up from 4% in 2001). The manner in which these families share resources and their living space is shaped by the economic, demographic and social contexts in which they live. Exploring how the family home adapts and evolves can teach us about family relationships and family resiliency.

More seniors are living with their grandchildren

Intergenerational relationships are on the rise in Canada, with population aging and increased life expectancy giving different generations more time to build and strengthen bonds. According to Statistics Canada, 16.1% of the total population is now aged 65 years or older, outnumbering the under-15 age group for the first time in Canada’s history. Life expectancy at age 65 is currently at a record high of 22 (87 years old) for women and 19 years (84 years old) for men.

Advances in home care, public transportation, assistive technologies and increased mobility have made it possible for more seniors and elders to decide where and how to live–and a growing number are now sharing a roof with their children and grandchildren.

According to the 2011 General Social Survey, growing numbers of children aged 14 and under are living with grandparents. In 2011, 4.8% of children lived with at least one grandparent, up from 3.3% in 2011. While parents are typically also living in these homes, 12% of co-residing grandparents are only living with their grandchildren in “skip-generation” households.

Multi-generational living more common among Indigenous and immigrant families

Indigenous and immigrant families – both of which account for a growing share of Canada’s population – are more likely than others to live with grandma and grandpa, for cultural and economic reasons. Among Indigenous families, 11% of grandparents reporting an Aboriginal identity live with their grandchildren (14% of First Nations, 22% of Inuit and 5% of Métis grandparents).

Grandparents Living with Grandchildren Chart

Immigrant families are also more likely to live in multi-generational households than their Canadian-born counterparts, a living arrangement that is often used as a financial management strategy for recent immigrants while they’re settling in to their new country. Whereas immigrants accounted for 26% of the overall population in Canada aged 45 and over in 2011, they accounted for more than one-half of all co-residing grandparents (54%).

A greater number of young adults are living in the parental home

While only 2.7% of private households in Canada are (three-generation) multi-generational households, it’s important to note that this statistic doesn’t tell the full story. Not included in Statistics Canada’s definition of multi-generational households are those that consist solely of parents and their adult children, a two-generation living arrangement that has been steadily increasing for decades as youth have faced tough labour markets, increased student debt and rising life costs.

The proportion of young adults aged 20 to 29 living in the parental home has increased from 27% in 1981 to 42% in 2011. This societal shift has reduced the stigma associated with young adults living in their parental home.

With a greater number of seniors living longer, a growth in the number of Indigenous and immigrant families (who are more likely to live in multi-generational homes) and a greater number of young adults are living in the parental home, multi-generational living will likely continue to grow in Canada. The high cost of housing also plays a role, with the average price of a home now more than $430,000 across the country, and reaching a high of $722,000 in Greater Vancouver.

Seniors provide and receive care in multi-generational homes

Some families live in multi-generational households because it allows the younger generations to provide care for their senior relatives, who benefit from the company of loved ones in a familial setting. Regular company with family members can prevent social isolation among seniors, which research has shown can have wide-ranging detrimental effects on their health and well-being. This can be particularly important for widowed grandparents, who account for one-quarter of co-residing grandparents.

Sometimes the senior generation in multi-generational homes is the source of care and support, with many making significant contributions to family finances. More than half (50.3%) report at least some responsibility for household payments, with a much higher share contributing when there’s a lone-parent middle generation (75%), or if they live in skip-generation households (80%).

Many of the 600,000 grandparents who live with their grandchildren provide care for their grandchildren when the parents are at work, at school or running errands. This can have a significant impact on family finances, since child care costs can consume a significant portion of family income. This is particularly true for parents of infants, since infant child care spaces are not only the hardest to find, but also the most expensive, typically exceeding $1,000 per month (with the exception of Quebec, which has much lower average costs due to its $7.30-per-day child care policy) and reaching a high of nearly $1,700 in Toronto.

The middle generation in multi-generational households can face numerous overlapping stressors from caring for both parents and children, which has led to them being labelled the “sandwich generation” in the media. Cohabitation can help avoid or reduce some of the stress and costs that might otherwise result from providing care to a parent who lives out of town or in another province – so it is perhaps not surprising that nearly one-quarter (24%) of Canadians who provided care to their parents in 2012 lived with the care recipient(s).

Co-residing parents and young adults make diverse contributions to family finances

Young adults in multi-generational homes give and receive support in diverse ways. A growing number provide care to family members with long-term health conditions, disabilities or age-related conditions. In 2012, 27% of the 15–29 age group provided care to family, with grandparents being the most common care recipient. But they help out in many other ways as well, such as with housework, errands and child care. In turn, living in the family home provides young adults with diverse forms of support as well, which can include room and board, meals and the use of facilities (e.g. laundry).

Living in multi-generational households can have economic advantages for all residents, as income can be pooled and household costs can be split among people in the household. The resulting savings can help to protect families from poverty and food insecurity. In a 2010 study of multi-generational living in the United States following the Great Recession, researchers found that the poverty rate in multi-generational homes was lower than that of their single-generational counterparts (11.5% and 14.6%, respectively). For those without jobs, the difference was far more pronounced: poverty rates for unemployed Americans was 17.5% for those living in multi-generational households, compared with 30.3% for those living in other households.

Creativity and adaptability facilitate shared living

No matter its size, every home has limited space, and families are deploying creative solutions to share a home while respecting and maintaining the independence of all involved. Some have set up accessory dwelling units (ADUs) in their homes for their parents that have been designed for senior living, sometimes referred to as “granny flats” or “in-law suites.” The renovations involved in establishing these living spaces are often relatively minor and can allow seniors to live in homes with little need for assistance and reduced risk of injury.

Architects and homebuilders associations are taking note of the increase in multi-generational living. Floor plans and building designs targeted at multi-generational living have become a selling point for this growing market. Often, these designs incorporate a “home within a home” – that is, a full home with a separate, private apartment connected or embedded. Extra living spaces can have their own separate entrance or they can share one with the primary living space. Multi-generational homes sometimes feature open floor plans and wider doorways and hallways, which can allow for better traffic flow. Generally speaking, the more generations living under one roof, the more versatile the house has to be.

Multi-generational living reflects family adaptability

Multi-generational living can involve some tensions and challenges, but it can also benefit families, allowing for stronger intergenerational relations, diverse options for the management of family finances and household work. While it creates opportunities for care and support, multi-generational living is a complex, dynamic living arrangement that benefits from communication, respect and boundaries.

Multi-generational households aren’t a recent innovation. They were more common prior to the Second World War than they are today, so the recent increase in this living arrangement is not uncharted territory for families by any means. Like all shifts and trends in living arrangements over time, it demonstrates how families adapt and react to their ever-changing circumstances, and respond to the social and economic climate.


SOURCES

David Macdonald and Martha Friendly, The Parent Trap: Child Care Fees in Canada’s Big Cities (November 2014), Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.

Anne Milan, Nadine Laflamme and Irene Wong, “Diversity of Grandparents Living with Their Grandchildren,” Insights on Canadian Society, Statistics Canada catalogue no. 75-006-X (April 2015).

National Seniors Council, “The Impact of Social Isolation on Seniors’ Quality of Life and Well-being,” Report on the Social Isolation of Seniors (November 2014).

Statistics Canada, “Portrait of Families and Living Arrangements in Canada,” Census Analytical Products, Statistics Canada catalogue no. 98-312-X-2011001 (September 2012).

image_print
2017-02-01T15:58:08+00:00
The Vanier Institute of the Family is a national, independent, charitable organization dedicated to understanding the diversity and complexity of families and the reality of family life in Canada.

Leave A Comment